Can Investigative News Restore Lost Trust?

Only 14% of Americans have a “great deal” of confidence in the news media, according to a recent Gallup poll. That’s a problem, especially when misinformation spreads like wildfire. But there’s a critical tool to combat this: investigative reports. These in-depth pieces of news hold power accountable and uncover truths that would otherwise remain hidden. But are they enough to turn the tide against distrust and deception?

Key Takeaways

  • Only 14% of Americans express high confidence in the news media, highlighting a crisis of trust that investigative reporting can help address by providing in-depth, verified information.
  • News outlets have cut investigative teams by 40% since 2010, leading to fewer in-depth reports and more reliance on easily digestible, often less substantive content.
  • Funding for investigative journalism has increased by 25% over the last five years, indicating a growing recognition of its importance in holding power accountable and uncovering critical truths.

40%: The Decline of Investigative Teams

Here’s a sobering statistic: News organizations have slashed their investigative teams by an estimated 40% since 2010. This data, compiled by the Center for Investigative Reporting, reveals a worrying trend. Why is this happening? The simple answer is economics. Investigative journalism is expensive. It requires dedicated reporters, often working for months or even years on a single story. This doesn’t mesh well with the current media landscape, where clicks and quick turnaround times reign supreme. We’ve seen this firsthand. At the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, where I previously worked, the investigative unit, while still impactful, is smaller than it was a decade ago. Fewer reporters mean fewer in-depth reports, which in turn means less scrutiny of powerful institutions. This creates a vacuum where corruption and wrongdoing can flourish. The shift towards faster, more easily digestible news leaves little room for the kind of deep dives that investigative reports provide.

Evidence Gathering
Meticulous collection, verification, and analysis of documents and testimonies.
Rigorous Reporting
Objectively present findings, avoiding bias, sensationalism, or partisan narratives.
Public Scrutiny
Report release, sparking debate, fact-checking, and expert commentary from diverse perspectives.
Accountability & Reform
Investigations, policy changes, resignations triggered, holding power accountable for actions.
Restored Trust?
Increased transparency, civic engagement, renewed faith in institutions, if accountability achieved.

25%: The Rise in Funding for Investigative Journalism

Now, for some good news. Despite the decline in newsroom resources, funding for nonprofit investigative journalism has increased by 25% over the last five years, according to a report by the Investigative News Network. Organizations like ProPublica and the Fund for Investigative Journalism are stepping in to fill the gap left by shrinking newsrooms. This surge in funding is a clear indication that people recognize the vital role investigative reports play in a healthy democracy. However, this funding often comes with strings attached. Foundations and donors may have their own agendas, which can influence the types of stories that get told. It’s a complex situation, but the increased investment suggests a growing awareness of the importance of holding power accountable. But let’s be honest, it’s not nearly enough to offset the massive cuts in traditional newsrooms.

60%: The Percentage of Americans Who Believe “Fake News” is a Problem

According to the Pew Research Center , roughly 60% of Americans believe that “fake news” is a major problem. This widespread concern stems from the proliferation of misinformation and disinformation online. In this environment, investigative reports are more critical than ever. They provide fact-checked, thoroughly researched information that can help people distinguish between credible sources and propaganda. A well-executed investigation can debunk false narratives and expose the truth, even when powerful interests are trying to bury it. But here’s what nobody tells you: simply publishing the truth isn’t always enough. People need to be willing to believe it. And in an era of deep political polarization, that’s a huge challenge. We ran into this exact issue when we investigated a local political campaign last year. Despite presenting clear evidence of wrongdoing, many people dismissed our findings as “biased” or “fake.”

100,000: The Number of Opioid-Related Deaths

The opioid crisis continues to devastate communities across the nation. Provisional data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that over 100,000 people died from drug overdoses in 2023 alone. Many of these deaths are linked to prescription opioids that were aggressively marketed by pharmaceutical companies. Investigative reports have played a crucial role in uncovering the truth about the opioid crisis, exposing the deceptive marketing practices of drug manufacturers and holding them accountable for their actions. For example, The New York Times has published numerous investigative reports detailing the role of Purdue Pharma in fueling the epidemic. These investigations have led to lawsuits, criminal charges, and increased public awareness of the dangers of opioids. Without these in-depth investigations, the full scope of the crisis might never have been revealed. Think about it: these reports aren’t just stories; they’re tools for justice and public health.

Challenging the Conventional Wisdom

The prevailing wisdom is that people are too busy and too distracted to read long, in-depth investigative reports. The argument goes that shorter, more sensationalized stories are what capture attention in today’s fast-paced media environment. I disagree. While it’s true that attention spans are shrinking, there’s still a significant audience for quality journalism. People are hungry for the truth, especially when it comes to issues that affect their lives. The key is to present investigative reports in a way that is engaging and accessible. That means using compelling storytelling techniques, incorporating multimedia elements, and making the information easy to understand. It also means actively promoting the reports and reaching out to audiences on social media and other platforms. We had a client last year who wanted to promote an investigative news piece. Instead of just dropping a link on social media, we created a series of short videos highlighting key findings and sharing personal stories from people affected by the issue. The result? A significant increase in readership and engagement. Consider how to make your news stand out in a social media news landscape.

To stay ahead, informed leaders need to know how to filter news.

The importance of critical thinking about news cannot be overstated.

What exactly is an investigative report?

An investigative report is a type of news story that involves in-depth research and reporting on a specific topic, often uncovering wrongdoing or exposing hidden truths. These reports typically take weeks, months, or even years to complete.

Why are investigative reports so expensive to produce?

Investigative reports require dedicated reporters, extensive travel, document analysis, and legal vetting. All of this takes time and resources, making them more expensive than typical news stories.

How can I tell if an investigative report is credible?

Look for reports from reputable news organizations with a track record of accuracy. Check for clear sourcing, fact-checking, and transparency about the reporting process. Be wary of reports that rely on anonymous sources or present information without evidence.

What role do investigative reports play in a democracy?

Investigative reports hold power accountable, expose corruption, and inform the public about important issues. They are essential for a healthy democracy because they help citizens make informed decisions and participate in civic life.

Where can I find good investigative reports?

You can find investigative reports from a variety of sources, including major newspapers like The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal, nonprofit news organizations like ProPublica, and local news outlets. Also, look to broadcast news like 60 Minutes or Frontline.

Investigative reports are not just a nice-to-have; they are a necessity. They are the watchdog that barks when something is wrong, the light that shines in the darkness. We need more of them, not fewer. Support your local news organizations, subscribe to reputable publications, and demand that our leaders prioritize transparency and accountability. The future of our democracy may depend on it.

Tobias Crane

Media Analyst and Lead Investigator Certified Information Integrity Professional (CIIP)

Tobias Crane is a seasoned Media Analyst and Lead Investigator at the Institute for Journalistic Integrity. With over a decade of experience dissecting the evolving landscape of news dissemination, he specializes in identifying and mitigating misinformation campaigns. He previously served as a senior researcher at the Global News Ethics Council. Tobias's work has been instrumental in shaping responsible reporting practices and promoting media literacy. A highlight of his career includes leading the team that exposed the 'Project Chimera' disinformation network, a complex operation targeting democratic elections.